Evolution of the Amphibian Ear

The hearing organ of the inner ear was the last of the paired sense organs of amniotes to undergo formative evolution. As a mechanical sensory organ, the inner-ear hearing organ's function depends highly on its physical structure. Comparative studies suggest that the hearing organ of the earliest amniote vertebrates was small and simple, but possessed hair cells with a cochlear amplifier mechanism, electrical frequency tuning, and incipient micromechanical tuning. The separation of the different groups of amniotes from the stem reptiles occurred relatively early, with the ancestors of the mammals branching off first, approximately 320 million years ago. The evolution of the hearing organ in the three major lines of the descendents of the stem reptiles (e.g., mammals, birds-crocodiles, and lizards-snakes) thus occurred independently over long periods of time. Dramatic and parallel improvements in the middle ear initiated papillar elongation in all lineages, accompanied by increased numbers of sensory cells with enhanced micromechanical tuning and group-specific hair-cell specializations that resulted in unique morphological configurations. This review aims not only to compare structure and function across classification boundaries (the comparative approach), but also to assess how and to what extent fundamental mechanisms were influenced by selection pressures in times past (the phylogenetic viewpoint).

The zebrafish provides an important model for vertebrate inner ear development. The otic placode becomes visible at approximately 16 hours (at 28.5 degrees C) and forms a vesicle with a lumen by cavitation at approximately 18 hours. Two otoliths appear in the lumen by 19.5 hours, and at about 24 hours the first sensory hair cells are seen, grouped in two small patches, one beneath each otolith, corresponding to future maculae. Staining with fluorescent phalloidin reveals 10-20 hair cells in each macula by 42 hours; between 3 days and 7 days the numbers grow to approximately 80 per macula. Neurons of the statoacoustic ganglion are first visible by staining with HNK-1 antibody at about 24 hours. Serial sections and time-lapse films show that the neuronal precursors originate by delamination from the ventral face of the otocyst; the peak period of delamination is from 22 hours to 30 hours. The system of semicircular canals forms between 42 hours and 72 hours by outgrowth of protrusions from the walls of the otocyst to form pillars of tissue spanning the lumen. Three further clusters of hair cells also become visible in this period, forming the three cristae. Thus, by the end of the first week, all key components of the ear are present. Subsequent growth produces thousands more hair cells; additional neurons probably derive from proliferation of neuronal precursors within the ganglion. Although the timetable is species-specific, the principles of inner ear development in the zebrafish seem to be the same as in other vertebrates.